I stumbled across Agatha Kitchen Bar on my very first day in Mazatlán. I was walking down Ave Playa Gaviotas and it couldn’t help but catch my eye. Here was this sleek and modern restaurant that looked more like something you’d find in Vancouver instead of a coastal city in Mexico.
Now, it could have been very easy of me to assume Agatha was just another fancy place. We’ve all seen our fair share, you know the kind – lots of great décor, but little to offer on the menu or in terms of personality. But let me tell you, after experiencing Agatha first hand I can tell you it’s FULL of heart and soul.
No matter if you are a tourist visiting Mazatlán for a week, or if you’re an expat who is retiring in the city, Agatha is a restaurant you need to experience for yourself.
I met Agatha’s corporate chef, a talented guy named Miguel Angel Alvarez, who prepared a multi-course meal for us to sample.
He has been cooking for 16 years and is passionate about every meal he prepares. I’m always curious about what drives a person to be a chef, so I asked him what he loves most about it.
The Vibe at Agatha
One of the first things I noticed about Agatha was the other people dining. It was a complete mixed bag. There were a few business men with suits on at the bar, a table of tourists with their young kids, a booth with a local family celebrating a birthday, and a group of women having a girls night out. There were people in jeans and sandals and some with platforms and sequin dresses. The crowd was as diverse as you could imagine, and not something I expected to see.
When I asked Miguel about this, he mentioned it was something he wish more people knew about the restaurant:
The FOOD at Agatha
What kind of food to expect
Here is what you can expect to eat at Agatha: High quality steaks, delicious sea food, fresh salads, shareable plates and even made-on-demand sushi. It’s not your typical fine dining place. On their menu you’ll find fusions of dishes you’ve never thought of before but will be dying to try.
We took a tour of the kitchen and noticed that not only are their health and safety standards out of this world, but they do things right down to the last detail. Even all their bread is made daily in house.
Quality and Prices
What impressed me the most was how every dish seemed to have a entire story around it. It made me realize that this wasn’t the kind of place that just threw whatever dish would make the most profit onto the menu.
In fact, while we’re on the subject of money, it’s important to talk about menu prices. You might think that such a posh place would come with sky-high dining costs, but that assumption would be wrong. Agatha has priced themselves extremely fairly, especially when you consider quality, and has made a point to keep it that way.
Some of Agatha's Dishes
Here are some of the starters we personally sampled at Agatha.
So good! Hamachi is a tuna-like fish and this one was raw, drizzled with a ginger miso serrano sauce and topped with crispy onions. The fish was such good quality and almost had a buttery texture to it.
Beets, Goat Cheese, and Pistachios
We loved the flavour and texture combos with this dish. They started with thick cooked beets and topped them with marsh-mellow and crumbled pistachio nuts, sitting amongst arugula and goat cheese with seeds. The plate also had dabs of marsh-mellow and sweet sauce on it, making it quite a savoury starter.
These artichoke hearts aren't officially on Agatha's menu, but can be found just next door at their sister Italian restaurant, Vittore. I learned that the restaurant in fact gets its parmesan from Parmigiano-Reggiano, Italy which makes this yummy dish taste even better.
Roasted cauliflower soaked in zarandeado sauce. One of the most surprising dishes we tried. Miguel explained to us how they wanted to take the most humble, common and unassuming vegetable they could find, and make it into a great appetizer. He applied a cooking trick he picked up while studying in India to this vegetable to make the texture and taste just perfect and topped it with a rich and almost cheesy sauce.
Seared Beef Tenderloin
Thinly sliced and lightly seared beef topped with avocado, pickles, capers and pasilla peppers with a beef sauce reduction. My husband says it's an absolute melt in your mouth burst of flavour.
The New Winter Menu
Miguel wanted us to try out a few dishes on the new winter menu they are creating, of which we were happy to oblige.
One of the contenders for the new winter menu is his Beef Wellington.
Miguel had put this creation on his Instagram stories and my husband was immediately intrigued, especially when he saw how much work went into it. Light flakey pastry wrapped around mushrooms, herbs, spices, garlic and of course, a tender and juicy tenderloin. My husband said it was one of the best steak experiences he's ever had.
Another winter menu contenders is this Seared Tuna with an Asian Grapefruit Salad and Wasabi Potato Puree.
I like to think of myself as a tuna connoisseur of sorts and it's one food I always look forward to eating. This was definitely not a let down. The salad was cool, light and refreshing with a citrus punch and went perfectly with the incredibly satisfying cuts of tuna. I'm not sure I've ever had tuna with potato puree before, but it actually paired wonderfully and gave the dish some weight.
More Vegetarian & Vegan Options
Something else coming to the new winter menu will be more plant-based options.
Miguel mentioned how even though many people still love their meat, the world is quickly waking up to how much damage the industry is taking on our planet. He is happy to introduce more plant-based dished to help turn people on to eating more fresh produce.
Flan & Sorbet
Any flan fans who are reading, cover your eyes…. I have to admit I have always disliked flan. Something about the texture has never convinced me it's a dessert I want on my plate. I know it's been a long-standing hit in Mexico for decades, but I still never grew accustomed to it.
When Miguel brought out this flan, at first I was worried, but that was until I tasted it. It's not your typical tasteless flan. Plus the texture is heavenly! Put together with crumble, fresh fruits and some of the best fruit sorbet I've ever had…it was exquisite.
Spiced Chocolate Lava Cake
Miguel told us a story about the old kinds of hot cocoa you'd find in Mexico back in the day. It was pretty strong, gritty and cheap, and the flavour wasn't all that refined. To combat that, people used to add spices like cinnamon, chile and cardamom to the drink to make it more palatable. This chocolate lava cake is a representation of that tradition, with an almost christmas-y taste to it.
The Drinks at Agatha
One of the things you’ll notice while dining at Agatha is the beautiful bar in the centre of the restaurant with skilled bartenders creating sophisticated cocktails.
Instead of seeing bartenders using artificial mixes and generic bases to create any old drink, you’ll see them grinding up fine herbs and squeezing fresh fruit to make each cocktail a work of art.
Personally, I’m in love with Agatha. After seeing first-hand how much effort and care they put into even the tiniest detail, I couldn’t imagine not being a raving fan.
Book a table, you'll be glad you did!